What Does a Mortons Neuroma Feel Like Ouch, these Mortons Neuroma’s can really hurt the ball of your forefoot! At first, you’re like…. have I got a small pebble in my shoe, or am I walking on a crease in my sock! With a Mortons Neuroma you’ll really feel a sharp pain under your foot and it will make you want to take your shoe off and squeeze your foot. The pain is usually between the 3rd and 4th toe and some patient’s tell us they have this burning sensation too or a numbness that extends into the small toes. … Continue reading Mortons Neuroma